Categorised | Big Brother, Civil Liberties, Conservatives, General, Labour, Lib Dems |

MPs’ fail to gauge the mood of the public

I don’t know whether Shahid Malik has a case to answer, only time will tell, but what he is guilty of is failing to capture and understand the mood of the public. Malik decided to come out fighting, in doing so, he came across as belligerent, arrogant and self-righteous, all of the attributes we despise in anyone, but especially those in positions of power, such as our politicians. It precisely this type of finger pointing, Holier Than Thou, I am better than you attitude, that infuriates the public. So instead of the public listening to what Malik was saying, they were concentrating on how he was saying it! So, the Minister for Justice believes that he should be considered ‘innocent until proven guilty’ whilst many in this country have been denied that long held right by HIS government! Further evidence, if it were needed, that most members of parliament really are hypocrites.

Of course Malik is not the only MP that has decided to go on the attack, but he is the latest, mostly, for some reason, Labour MP’s. Yet all they are doing is fanning the flames. How ironic that New Labour invented ’spin’ yet it doesn’t appear to be able to reign in its MP’s when it needs to most. Whilst anger is universal, I get the impression that most is directed at Labour MP’s, almost certainly since they are the party in power that has failed the vast majority of the public. Therefore, it is perhaps New Labour MP’s, more that any, that need to be contrite?

I am not convinced however, that all of this anger is about expense account abuse, I believe it is the culmination of the way that MP’s, Labour in particular, have and continue to demonstrate that they are incapable of admitting that they could be wrong or have made mistakes and that starts right at the top with Gordon Brown.

Two thirds of the public want a general election, which is double the number that was needed to give this government such a massive majority, but the will of the people is ignored. Democracy is generally described as being: a form of government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised directly by them or by their elected agents under a free electoral system. Yet, our elected representative know that the majority of people want a change of government, but they are too arrogant to grant one. That is dangerous. Malik said that the expense scandal was in danger of destroying democracy, not so, it is the smug, self-serving and remote attitude of MP’s in general and Labour MP’s in particular that will destroy our democracy.

David Davies has suggested that many members of parliament are considering stepping down, leaving politics altogether, because they dislike the fact that all MP’sare being tarred with the same brush. Personally I think that is the best thing that could happen, David Davies probably thinks the public should be concerned, I don’t believe that to be true. The public want wholesale change, if the main parties don’t provide that through the retirement or deselection of existing MP’s, then I suspect we will get it by default with an increasing number of independent MP’s (and smaller parties) being voted in at the next election. If the main parties do not want to become also rans, then they must listen to the will of the people.

One of the problems with the mainstream parties and I have said this before, is the fact that they select candidates from such a small pool. This means that we end up with lots of candidates (for MP’s) that think the same, talk the same and act the same. Not like you and I, but like each other. It is like being ruled by aliens. It is hardly a good example of democracy in action, if the only people we are allowed to vote for within the big parties, are those that are selected from the same tiny pool of limited talent, which is designed to positively discriminate against or, exclude real people.

Mainstream parties should spread their nets wider, recruit the best talent, so that these people can take up those key positions when, or if, the party get elected into power. Now is the time for party leaders to follow the will of the people. Never will they have a better opportunity than now to justify a wholesale clear-out of the many MP’s that are quite simply a waste of space. The party that is brave enough to do this, will align themselves most closely with the mood of the public, who want and demand change. In all probability, they will also be responsible for restoring the publics faith in politics, democracy and politicians. Party leaders need to understand that it is not optional, but essential, that the people of this country have trust and confidence in their politicians.

If I was a leader of one of the main parties I would seriously consider going on a recruitment drive to find the ‘best of the best’. I would be looking to recruit real people, those with expertise in business, health, education, economics and so on. Individuals that sounded like people, not politicians, that were sincere rather than smooth,  those that could demonstrate gravitas and sincerity rather than a dismissive attitude towards alternative opinions or the will of the people. One other thing all politician’s must take into account regarding this whole sorry saga is, whilst they may object to being tarred with the same brush (as ‘dodgy’ MP’s), that is exactly what is happening to the people of this country. The public are being forced into a situation where theirright to privacy is being stolen by this Governments Big Brother ’database state’, which records our emails, mobile phone calls, health records, children’s educational needs, DNA, internet traffic, vehicle movements, travel arrangements…and now wants our biometric data, ID cards, the ability to profile etc, etc. The state is treating us all like suspects, it is bringing in petty rules, regulations and laws (3607 in 12 years) that seeks to criminalise even the most mundane things. It is has unashamedly used the fear of crime and terrorism to introduce what can only amount to state control and yes, state terrorism. It has got to stop.

Politicians don’t like it when the public think they are all on the make, or criminals, but then, we also dislike being considered potential criminals that must be spied on, tracked and hounded. In the end, politicians only have themselves to blame, they are paying the price for their disconnect from, and contempt for, the public. The expense scandal is a wake up for all MP’s, best they look at what is below the surface, as well as the actual event, lest they miss a golden opportunity to put power back with the people, by introducing genuine ‘root and branch’ reform within their own party’s.

7 Comments For This Post

  1. David Waddell Says:

    I quite agree. I think the tone is crucial, and unfortunately for Mr Malik, this matter falls within the jurisdiction of the court of public opinion (CoPO). His party’s deputy leader believes some things should be decided there, and in his case it will be. In the CoPO, one is guilty until proven innocent. So Mr Malik is guilty, and so is Elliot Morley, Andrew MacKay and a number of others. The fact that some of these characters are NOT guilty is a side issue. The CoPO has decided and it is the same court to whom the appeal must be made.

    For all politicians are despised by so many, now is the time for them to practice the art of politics with a deft hand. Those who do so will rescue their careers or improve their public standing.

    The voters are in charge now, so MP’s need to show respect, not contempt. It may be that they are innocent, but if they fail to show respect to the voters, they will be cast into the political wilderness where there will be wailing and gnashing of teeth…

  2. Frustrated Voter Says:

    @ David Waddell: Interesting times are ahead and I for one believe the angry public outcry has been long overdue, but will eventually prove to be a good thing for democracy and accountability. MP’s are facing a well deserved backlash and they must start to realise that the public can bite back. And, let’s face it, the public has been treated quite contemptuously by a good many MP’s, especially, but not exclusively, by New Labour MP’s. There are one or two that are coming out well, but they are listening and responding, they are not resorting to ‘attack’ as being the best type of defence. It should sort the men from the boys (metaphorically speaking of course).

  3. Charlie Says:

    Malik behaviour was almost unbelievable but that is the untouchable attitude of our MPs, almost as if it is none of our business what they spend our money on. Or Lord Foulkes’ how dare we find out rant on the BBC. I’m just waiting for one of them to say, ‘Let them eat cake.’

    I was actually quite impressed with David Cameron’s stance on this. I watched his speech and was expecting the usual wishy washy stuff but he was pretty firm and seemed to be actually listening to the public. He has once again out manoeuvred Gordon Brown.

    As for MPs stepping down, we can only hope! But I think the next general election will be a massive step forward for independent MPs and fringe parties.

  4. Frustrated Voter Says:

    @ Charlie: Yes, Malik and Foulkes got it completely wrong. The only point I would make about Cameron is, he hasn’t yet made clear that those that have acted “excessively” within his party, could face deselection. I believe Brown, or at least the NEC are going to propose this as the ultimate sanction, so if Cameron doesn’t move smartish, he risks being outmaneuvered.

  5. Free the British Says:

    I found Malik’s TV rebuttal to be arrogant and aggressive. Of course he has a case to answer and I am sick and tired of people being put in place because of their race or gender. He said that he earned more money before he was an MP, well great, he can go back and do what he was doing before, no one will miss him.

  6. My Way Says:

    I believe that the Labour party have done a great deal of damage to our country over their 3 parliamentary terms. However, I see little in the Conservatives that would mark out any great change. Cameron lacks conviction. I am beginning to warm to the LibDems who I previously though were a bit of a joke.

  7. JTC Says:

    All you ever need to know about Shahid Malik and how it is that he manages to remain in the Cabinet - http://acidrabbi.blogspot.com/2009/06/shahid-malik-escapologist.html

Leave a Reply

  • Popular
  • Latest
  • Comments
  • Tags
  • Subscribe
Advertise Here

Other Sites